PD Notebook Presidential Jet Report Disciplinary Action Lawsuit
Higher Court Overturns First Ruling, Finds 'Two-Member System' Not Unlawful
Appeal Filed After Considering Various Legal Circumstances

Eugene Group has filed an appeal against the first-instance court ruling that revoked the approval for changing the largest shareholder of YTN.

Eugene Group Appeals First-Instance Ruling Revoking YTN Approval View original image

On December 4, Eugene ENT announced in an official statement, "We have appealed to the Seoul High Court against the first-instance ruling by the Seoul Administrative Court that revoked the approval for changing the largest shareholder of YTN."


Eugene ENT stated, "There are over ten main cases in the first and second instances disputing procedural flaws in the two-member system of the Korea Communications Commission, and the judgments have varied depending on the case." The company emphasized, "On November 28, the Seoul High Court, in a case where MBC filed a lawsuit against the Korea Communications Commission to cancel disciplinary action related to the 'PD Notebook Presidential Jet Exclusion Report,' interpreted that 'the members present refer to those who are officially in office at the time of the decision, according to the legal wording.' Unlike the first-instance ruling, the court determined that decisions made under the two-member system were not procedurally unlawful." The company further asserted, "This is significant as it marks the first judgment on the merits by a higher court regarding the two-member system of the Korea Communications Commission."


On November 28, the Seoul Administrative Court's Administrative Division 3 (Presiding Judge Choi Sujin) ruled in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by the YTN Employee Stock Ownership Association against the Korea Communications Commission, seeking to revoke the approval for the change of the largest shareholder. The court found that the decision made by the two-member system of the Korea Communications Commission at the time was procedurally flawed and therefore unlawful. The court stated, "It is desirable for the defendant's major decisions to be made with all five members appointed and present, requiring the approval of at least three members," and added, "Even if there are fewer than five members due to unavoidable circumstances, the defendant, as a collegial body, must function with at least three members present for decisions to be valid."



Eugene ENT said, "We proceeded with the appeal process after considering various legal circumstances and trends in case law," and added, "We will monitor the progress of the appellate trial and consider issuing further statements as necessary."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing