Cheon Daeyeop, Director of Court Administration, Voices Concerns Over Special Tribunal for Treason
"Significant Potential for Restriction of Judicial Independence, A Very Serious Matter"
"Trials Could Be Prolonged... Contrary to Public Expectations"

Cheon Daeyeop, Director of the Court Administration Office, expressed strong concerns regarding the bill to establish a Special Tribunal for Treason. At the plenary session of the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee on the 3rd, Director Cheon stated, "The separation of powers and judicial independence that we have enjoyed under the 1987 Constitution could fade into history," and added, "I consider this a very serious matter because I believe there is significant potential for the independence of the judiciary to be restricted."


Cheon Daeyeop, Director of the Court Administration Office. The Asia Business Daily DB

Cheon Daeyeop, Director of the Court Administration Office. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

The bill to establish a Special Tribunal for Treason, currently being promoted by the ruling party, stipulates that the President of the Constitutional Court, the Minister of Justice, and the National Judges' Representative Conference (Judges' Council) each recommend three candidates to form the 'Special Tribunal for Treason Candidate Recommendation Committee,' which will then recommend twice the number of required candidates to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Director Cheon remarked, "Ultimately, the Constitutional Court will be tasked with reviewing the constitutionality of this bill, but having the referee also play as a participant fundamentally contradicts the rules of the game, the rules of the trial," and continued, "In this case, I believe the law anticipates the creation of a Special Constitutional Tribunal for Treason as well."


Director Cheon also raised concerns about the participation of the Minister of Justice in the tribunal recommendation committee, stating, "The Minister of Justice represents prosecutorial and administrative powers, and we have a long history of suffering due to the excessive exercise of prosecutorial authority." He added, "Recently, in continuation of that history, the head of the prosecution became president and imposed unconstitutional martial law, causing significant harm to the public. Given this recent history, it is our position that allowing the Ministry of Justice-an institution representing investigative and administrative powers-to intervene in the judiciary constitutes a significant restriction or infringement on judicial authority, and I cannot help but point this out."


He also voiced concerns that the introduction of the Special Tribunal for Treason could lead to prolonged delays in trials. Director Cheon stated, "The tribunal currently handling the treason case has declared that it will certainly conclude and deliver a verdict by January or February of next year, and I believe the fate of the judiciary is at stake in this matter. If the Special Tribunal for Treason bill is passed and the trial is suspended due to constitutional issues, the proceedings could be halted for an extended period, which I fear would run counter to the public's expectations."


On the 3rd, at the 16th plenary meeting of the 429th National Assembly (regular session) Legislation and Judiciary Committee held at the National Assembly in Yeouido, Seoul, a bill to establish a 'Special Tribunal for Treason' (Special Court for Treason) dedicated to handling the treason case involving former President Yoon Seokyeol and others related to the December 3 martial law incident is being passed under the ruling party's leadership. Yonhap News

On the 3rd, at the 16th plenary meeting of the 429th National Assembly (regular session) Legislation and Judiciary Committee held at the National Assembly in Yeouido, Seoul, a bill to establish a 'Special Tribunal for Treason' (Special Court for Treason) dedicated to handling the treason case involving former President Yoon Seokyeol and others related to the December 3 martial law incident is being passed under the ruling party's leadership. Yonhap News

View original image

On this day, the Legislation and Judiciary Committee passed the bill to establish the Special Tribunal for Treason under the leadership of the ruling party. The People Power Party strongly opposed the bill and the proposed crime of judicial distortion, even requesting the formation of an agenda coordination committee, but was overruled by the majority. Na Kyungwon, a member of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee from the People Power Party, criticized the bill, saying, "In short, this is a law to pick and choose judges if you don't like them, essentially a law to replace Judge Ji Guyoun," and added, "This not only violates the principle of random assignment of judges but also constitutes an infringement of the separation of powers by taking cases already being tried away from current judges and assigning them to others."



Jeon Hyunhee, a member of the Democratic Party of Korea, cited the case where the court dismissed the arrest warrant for People Power Party lawmaker Chu Kyungho, stating, "The judiciary is acting as a shield for the forces of treason," and added, "The National Assembly can no longer stand by and watch." The Democratic Party is currently seeking to have the bill, which passed the committee on this day, processed at a plenary session of the National Assembly within this month.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing