The Paradox of a "Total Ban" Unwanted by Workers
Instead of Erasing Innovation, We Must Design a Safer System

[THE VIEW]If Early Morning Delivery Stops, So Do Jobs View original image

Recently, the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) launched large-scale actions calling for a ban on early morning delivery services by major distribution companies, including Coupang. Although social dialogue has continued, there is still a tug-of-war between the KCTU, which demands a complete overhaul of the early morning delivery system, and the platforms, which insist that such demands are unacceptable.


The KCTU views early morning delivery simply as a means of exploitation. However, in reality, its role is far more complex. The combination of platform companies and technological advancement has created new jobs and brought economic benefits to consumers, delivery workers, and small business owners alike.


In the past, the idea of taking orders at night and delivering them by dawn existed. However, matching real-time orders with inventory and optimizing delivery routes and driver assignments for early morning delivery incurred excessive information processing costs. As a result, it was an unviable and unrealistic model.


Today, however, AI can learn from past purchase data to quickly predict which products will sell and in what quantities by the next morning. Based on these predictions, goods can be pre-stocked at regional logistics centers, and personnel and vehicles can be allocated in advance. In other words, the growth of platform companies and the active use of IT have explosively expanded the delivery industry.


The daily volume of 1.5 million early morning deliveries clearly demonstrates how logistics innovation, driven by IT companies and digital technology, is reshaping our daily lives and local economies. People in urgent need of income have gained additional work opportunities during the early morning hours, while for middle-aged and older individuals whose livelihoods have been weakened by the economic downturn, early morning work has become a kind of last-resort job-a safety net.


For small business owners, these platforms offer new sales channels that help generate higher profits. Products like farm-fresh tangerines or eggs from small-scale farms, which previously could only be ordered by phone, can now participate in the market.


For consumers, early morning delivery has provided the benefit of faster and more convenient services; for workers, it has created new jobs and income opportunities; and for small business owners, it has opened digital sales channels. In this sense, it can be seen as a change that has brought benefits to society as a whole.

A Coupang logistics center in downtown Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

A Coupang logistics center in downtown Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Coupang delivery drivers themselves are also opposed to a complete ban on early morning delivery. Contrary to the claims of the KCTU, a significant number of Coupang delivery drivers actually want to maintain early morning delivery. While it is true that night shifts are demanding, the higher pay compensates for the difficulty, so restricting these shifts would directly lead to reduced income. Ultimately, a blanket ban on early morning delivery would put simultaneous pressure on workers, the self-employed, and ordinary households, likely causing an immediate blow to the livelihoods of many.


It is a misunderstanding of reality to expect that consumers, if deprived of early morning delivery, will simply give up convenience and return to standard delivery. With global platforms-especially those from China-rapidly entering the market and establishing logistics centers across the country, demand will inevitably shift toward options that are more convenient and price-competitive.


While I agree with the KCTU’s principle of "life over speed," the solution should not be an extreme, all-out ban that destroys the industry itself. Nowhere in the United States, Singapore, or Europe is there a regulation that eliminates the early morning delivery industry through a total ban. Instead, these countries tend to focus on detailed regulations to protect workers.


Korea, too, should move toward designing more sophisticated safety mechanisms, such as setting maximum working hours and restructuring compensation systems, rather than imposing bans. Instead of cutting off the fruits of innovation brought about by IT advancement, the focus should be on how to distribute them more safely and fairly. I hope the government approaches the current debate over banning early morning delivery-which directly affects the market and consumer sovereignty-with more caution than ever.



Professor Kyung Nakyung, Department of Computer Science, National University of Singapore


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing