"The disadvantages suffered by the plaintiff are excessively large compared to the public interest to be achieved by the cancellation... Abuse of discretionary power"

The court has ruled that the Public Procurement Service's decision to revoke a small business's designation as an excellent product supplier, on the grounds that part of its solar power generation equipment was produced by outsourcing, was excessive and therefore unlawful.

Excellent Product Designation Revoked Over "Partial Outsourcing" of Solar Equipment... Court Rules Public Procurement Service’s Action Excessive View original image

According to the legal community on December 1, the 13th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Jin Hyunseop) recently ruled in favor of plaintiff Company A, a solar power system manufacturer, in its lawsuit against the head of the Public Procurement Service seeking the cancellation of the "restriction on bidding eligibility" and other related actions.


Company A was designated as an excellent procurement supplier for its solar power systems in both 2015 and 2021, signing private contracts with the Public Procurement Service and supplying these systems to various government agencies. However, in September last year, the Public Procurement Service revoked this designation, stating, "During contract execution, Company A did not directly manufacture the support structures, which are structural components of the solar power generation equipment, but instead placed bulk orders for their production and installation with several other companies."


Company A argued, "The support structures are merely subsidiary materials that can be produced by outsourcing, and this does not constitute a violation of the direct production requirement." The company also contended that, given the ambiguity in the criteria for confirming direct production, the immediate revocation of the excellent product designation amounted to an abuse of discretion.


The court acknowledged the violation of the direct production requirement as pointed out by the Public Procurement Service. The court stated, "The structural components of solar power generation equipment are essential elements, and since the criteria for confirming direct production only exceptionally allow outsourcing for the junction box enclosure, modules, and inverters, the structures and their parts, including the support structures, are also subject to direct production."



However, the court found the severity of the sanction to be excessive. The court took into account several factors: the criteria for direct production did not sufficiently and clearly define the scope of structures or the production process; subsequent guidelines from the Ministry of SMEs and Startups redefined the direct production requirements for structures to focus on 'on-site installation'; Company A had continued to supply products diligently to client agencies; and the installed equipment was operating normally. The court stated, "Given that the disadvantage suffered by the plaintiff as a result of this sanction is excessively large compared to the public interest that could be achieved, this sanction violates the principle of proportionality and constitutes an abuse of discretion." Accordingly, the court canceled the decision to revoke the excellent product designation.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing