Plaintiff Wins First Trial in Lawsuit to Cancel Largest Shareholder Change
Eugene Group: "We Will Thoroughly Analyze the Ruling and Actively Appeal"

Eugene Group has announced its intention to appeal the court's decision to revoke the Korea Communications Commission's approval of the change in YTN's largest shareholder.

On the 28th, Eugene Group stated regarding the first trial result of the lawsuit filed by the YTN Employee Stock Ownership Association against the Korea Communications Commission to cancel the approval for the change of the largest shareholder, "Eugene Group participated in this lawsuit as an auxiliary participant for the Korea Communications Commission and is therefore able to file its own appeal," adding, "We will thoroughly review the court's written judgment and actively decide on an appeal."

On this day, the 3rd Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court (Presiding Judge Choi Sujin) ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit filed by the YTN labor union. The decision was based on the reasoning that the resolution made by the Korea Communications Commission, which at the time operated under a "two-person system," was procedurally flawed and therefore illegal.

The court stated, "When interpreting the Korea Communications Commission Act, which stipulates that resolutions are made by a majority of the incumbent commissioners, one should not be confined to the literal meaning of the text. It is necessary to comprehensively consider the legislative intent to guarantee the freedom of broadcasting as protected by the Constitution, and to ensure the freedom, public nature, and independence of broadcasting by establishing the Korea Communications Commission as a collegial administrative body," adding, "As a collegial administrative body, the Korea Communications Commission requires mutual discussion, persuasion, and deliberation in its decision-making process."

The court further noted, "If there are only two incumbent commissioners, while it may be possible to exchange differing opinions, if one opposes, a resolution cannot be made, making it practically impossible for the principle of majority rule to function."

The court continued, "It is desirable for major decisions of the Korea Communications Commission to be made with the approval of at least three out of five fully appointed commissioners. Even if, due to unavoidable circumstances, there are fewer than five commissioners, the Commission must have at least three incumbents for resolutions to be made in order to function substantively as a collegial body."

Previously, Eugene ENT, a special purpose company established by Eugene Corporation and Dongyang, acquired a 30.95% stake in YTN held by KEPCO KDN and the Korea Racing Authority. On February 7 last year, the Korea Communications Commission approved Eugene ENT's application for the change of the largest shareholder.

In response, the YTN branch of the National Union of Media Workers and the Employee Stock Ownership Association filed a lawsuit on the merits and an application for injunction, challenging the Korea Communications Commission's "two-person system" resolution at the time. The injunction applications they filed were previously dismissed or rejected.



This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing