[Reporter’s Notebook] VC Is Not a Lending Company View original image

"There have been cases where a venture capital firm exercises a put option (stock repurchase right) against an investee company and immediately hands the matter over to a debt collection agency, resulting in the founder being harassed by collection calls on a daily basis."


This was stated by Kim Sunghoon, Managing Partner at Mission Law Firm, who spoke as a presenter at the "Productive Finance Blind Spots and Development Directions" forum jointly hosted by the Korea Entrepreneurship Society and The Asia Business Daily on November 22. Although several years have passed since the full implementation of the prohibition on requiring founders to provide joint surety in venture investments, he pointed out that put options and various joint liability agreements are effectively taking the place of the now-banned joint guarantees.


He described the current state of venture investment in Korea as "credit (loans) disguised as investment." While on the surface, equity investment is supposed to support the founder's growth and share in the results, he noted that contracts often still contain clauses that, in effect, require founders to guarantee the return of the principal and interest on the investment.


He also cited as background the fact that the starting point of Korea's startup and venture finance has always been closer to "loans" than to "investments." As the government supported small and medium-sized enterprises for a long time in the form of loans, the perception that "borrowed money must be repaid" and the practice of joint guarantees became embedded in the structure of venture funds that combine the Fund of Funds and policy capital. He explained that venture capital firms have justified this culture by invoking their fiduciary duty to limited partners (LPs).


Three days after the forum, the National Assembly's Trade, Industry, Energy, SMEs and Startups Committee passed an amendment to the Venture Investment Promotion Act, which elevates the prohibition on joint liability for startup founders from administrative notice to statutory law. The amendment prohibits not only venture capital firms but also individual investment associations and startup accelerators from entering into investment contracts that require joint liability. As this is a livelihood-related bill with little disagreement between the ruling and opposition parties, it is highly likely to pass the National Assembly plenary session within the year.


The issue, however, is not just the wording of the law, but also the need to improve the culture of "venture capital" in Korea. LPs, venture capital firms, founders, and the government must move away from a game where profits are shared but all losses are shifted onto someone else. Discussions on how to accompany founders through follow-on investments, managing failures, and enabling restarts must begin at the earliest stages. It is also crucial to prevent other forms of de facto guarantees or "hidden toxic clauses" from filling the void left by the removal of joint liability provisions.



Startup founding inherently carries a failure rate of over 90%, yet it is a field that creates new national growth engines through technological and business model innovation. That is why we call unlisted companies that achieve valuations in the trillions of won despite long odds "unicorns." If we encourage failure and second chances but ultimately shift all the burden of failure onto individual founders, it will be difficult to discover the next unicorn. Whether the legal amendment will end in cynicism with "contracts and practices remaining unchanged," or become an opportunity to restore mutual trust in venture capital, will ultimately depend on the choices of market participants.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing