[Economy Pulse] The U.S. Shipbuilding Policy Toward China in Disarray and the MASGA Strategy View original image

Mainstream U.S. media outlets such as The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) and The New York Times (NYT) have harshly criticized President Donald Trump's China policy, describing it as inconsistent and suggesting that the United States is being led by China. While Trump widely promotes himself as having led negotiations to victory, in reality, he is suffering a reversal at the hands of China.


He has overlooked China's position in the global supply chain, and the weakening of the National Security Council within the White House has led to a lack of policy coordination. At the same time, President Trump has provoked trouble by making excessive statements for domestic political purposes. His "TACO" habit-provoking the other side and then shrinking back when they respond strongly-has become evident in U.S.-China relations.


Moreover, China holds decisive "choke points" that allow it to pressure the United States at any time. In key minerals and rare earth elements, China is the world's dominant supplier, and there is no country that can replace China in the supply of general consumer goods. While China is accustomed to U.S. containment efforts, the United States is unable to withstand decisive measures from China.


This year, President Trump has agreed to three rounds of tariff truces with China, claiming to have established a future-oriented relationship. However, objectively, China has firmly achieved its own interests, while the United States has been preoccupied with appeasing China. This raises questions about whether there is any real U.S. strategy toward China. The highlight was the U.S.-China summit held in Busan at the end of October. Amid critical media coverage, even Trump's own supporters have expressed opposition.


President Trump described the Busan U.S.-China summit as an "amazing meeting" and rated the negotiation results as "12 out of 10." In this summit, he had no choice but to agree to a one-year temporary truce in the trade war with China. With tariffs and a government shutdown looming, he could not ignore concerns about the midterm elections scheduled for November 3, 2026. Given the possibility of an unfavorable final judicial ruling on mutual tariffs next month, it is difficult for him to continue the trade war with China. Last week's phone call between the U.S. and Chinese leaders was also initiated at President Trump's request. In summary, the United States needed the U.S.-China summit more than China did. President Trump appeared anxious, while President Xi Jinping of China seemed relaxed.


Although it is fortunate that the two countries have agreed to maintain a cooperative relationship, even if temporarily, the problem is that the U.S. is losing consistency in its China policy. The United States agreed to defer and reduce tariffs (on fentanyl), and to suspend port entry fees for Chinese ships, while China agreed to defer export controls on rare earths, resume imports of U.S. soybeans, and crack down on illegal fentanyl. The number of concessions on both sides was similar.


However, the decision to suspend entry fees for Chinese ships has been strongly criticized by the U.S. Congress and major labor unions as undermining the rationale for reviving the U.S. shipbuilding industry. To counter China's dominance in global shipping and shipbuilding, the United States had invoked Section 301 of the Trade Act and planned to impose entry fees on Chinese ships and shipping companies. South Korea's MASGA strategy is also aligned with the U.S. sanctions on China's shipbuilding industry.


South Korea had promised investments to help revive the U.S. shipbuilding industry, but Trump changed his China policy directly related to this. U.S. labor unions even argue that this measure has undermined the commitment to revitalize the U.S. shipping and shipbuilding industries. Furthermore, the White House has dismantled the Shipbuilding Bureau within the National Security Council. It is fortunate that, immediately after the U.S.-China summit, China lifted sanctions on five affiliates of Hanwha, a key player in the MASGA strategy. However, the U.S. policy change toward China's shipping and shipbuilding industries will inevitably impact South Korea's MASGA strategy as well.



Jung Inkyu, Professor of International Trade at Inha University (Former Director-General for Trade Negotiations at the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy)


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing