Significant Gap Between Tax Assessment and Actual Value
Need for Valuation Linked to Corporate Profitability and Asset Value

[Insight & Opinion] Stock Price Manipulation to Avoid Inheritance Tax: The Root Cause Must Be Addressed View original image

In September 2024, KCGI, a private equity fund manager, paid around 58,000 won per share when acquiring shares from the major shareholder of Hanyang Securities. This price was more than five times higher than Hanyang Securities' market price on the exchange at the time, which was just above 10,000 won. KCGI explained that this amount reflected not only Hanyang Securities' net asset value (in the 40,000 won range) but also the actual value of its Yeouido headquarters building. While the building was recorded at 10 billion won on the books, its actual value was considered to exceed 100 billion won. In transactions between major shareholders, it is common for the 'fair value' to be determined by comprehensively considering the net asset value as a base, along with hidden asset value and goodwill premiums.


The issue lies in the method of corporate equity valuation under the tax code. The Inheritance and Gift Tax Act stipulates that, in the case of inherited or gifted listed shares, the value should be assessed based on the 'market price on the exchange.' However, this system leads to a significant discrepancy between the actual economic value and the valuation for taxation purposes. There are frequent cases where major shareholders intentionally lower the share price, for example, by disregarding shareholder returns, to reduce inheritance tax. Some companies, after decades as unlisted firms, seek a public listing just before an expected inheritance event. Such distortions ultimately result in a loss of national tax revenue and shift the burden onto minority shareholders and the general public.


Ironically, some claim that the solution to this problem is to drastically cut inheritance taxes. However, this is akin to arguing that, because some people sneak into a baseball stadium through a hole in the fence to avoid paying the entrance fee, the entrance fee should be abolished. The root of the problem is not the entrance fee, but the hole in the fence; similarly, it is not the inheritance tax rate, but the distortion in valuation methods that enables tax avoidance. Intentionally lowering a company's share price to reduce the taxable inheritance amount goes beyond tax planning and constitutes tax evasion, which should be seen as an act of violence that causes significant harm to many minority shareholders.


Recently, as seen in the amendment proposed by Democratic Party lawmaker Lee Soyoung, there have been attempts to calculate inheritance and gift taxes for listed companies with a price-to-book ratio (PBR) of 0.8 or lower based on intrinsic value, considering both asset value and earnings value. Such legislative efforts are positively viewed as measures to prevent inheritance tax avoidance by exploiting undervalued share prices. However, there remains a loophole in the valuation of unlisted shares, as it is still possible to manipulate earnings value through accounting practices. If a major shareholder intentionally reduces operating profit for several years or records temporary losses, the intrinsic value can be artificially distorted, unfairly reducing the tax burden.



Therefore, it is necessary to introduce a more rational system that links the valuation method to both a company's profitability and asset value. For example, companies with low profitability (where ROE is below a certain threshold) could be assessed primarily on net asset value, while companies with high profitability (where ROE exceeds a certain level) could have a 'profit premium' added to their net asset value, reflecting earnings value. This approach would prevent tax avoidance through simple accounting manipulation and create a structure in which transparent management performance is rewarded with fair valuation. Additionally, I would suggest that for shareholders of companies that achieve high share prices through excellent management and shareholder returns while also striving to increase employment and welfare for more employees, it would be desirable to devise ways to reduce their inheritance tax burden.

Suh Joonsik, Professor of Economics, Soongsil University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing