[KOSPI 5000 Midterm Review]② Ruling Party Pushes Alternative Legislation for Breach of Trust and Mandatory Tender Offer...Progress Remains Slow
Reflecting Business Community Concerns, but Progress Is Slow
Alternative Legislation for Breach of Trust Awaits Research Results
Mandatory Tender Offer Under Jurisdiction of Opposition Committee Chair
The Democratic Party of Korea, aiming to pass the third amendment to the Commercial Act within this year, is also focusing on supplementary legislation such as alternative laws for the crime of breach of trust and the mandatory public tender offer system, reflecting concerns from the business community. The main issue is the pace of these supplementary legislative efforts.
Alternative Legislation for Breach of Trust Proceeds Slowly... "If Delayed Further, Alternatives Will Be Considered"
Last month, the government and ruling party announced plans to abolish the crime of breach of trust under the Criminal Act and to pursue alternative legislation. The core objective is to improve the breach of trust offense, which hinders corporate management activities, in order to reduce harm to business operators and to strengthen civil liability. The business community, facing increased management burdens due to the Commercial Act amendment, has called for the swift abolition or relaxation of the breach of trust offense.
However, the preparation of alternative legislation for the breach of trust offense is progressing more slowly than the handling of the third amendment to the Commercial Act. Recently, Policy Committee Chairperson Han Jeongae stated at a press briefing, "It seems that preparing alternative legislation for the breach of trust offense will take more time than expected," adding, "Whether it takes a short or long time, it is necessary to conduct a research study." It is understood that the Ministry of Justice is currently reviewing the research study related to the alternative legislation. A key member of the task force for rationalizing economic criminal penalties and civil liability, which leads the party's internal discussions on the breach of trust offense, told The Asia Business Daily, "It appears that the work will be conducted in the form of a working group," and added, "It will likely take some time to complete the study."
The alternative legislation for the breach of trust offense being pursued by the Democratic Party may take the form of a special law that clearly defines the offense. The reason for the prolonged discussions is the need to categorize numerous cases. A task force member stated, "If we create a special law, there will be many related laws," and continued, "There are elements of punishment for breach of trust in various laws, so we need to consolidate and reorganize them."
For now, the only option is to wait for the results of the study. However, there are voices saying that if the process is excessively delayed, other alternatives must be considered. An assemblyman from the KOSPI 5000 Special Committee, which led the discussions on the Commercial Act, said, "Although a report on the alternative legislation was promised by mid-next month, if it takes longer, we may need to change our approach." Regarding alternatives, he explained, "If the principle of business judgment is included as a requirement, investigative agencies would also have to conduct investigations accordingly, so this could be one possible solution."
Ruling Party Open to Mandatory Public Tender Offer... But Relevant Committee Is Chaired by Opposition
The Democratic Party has stated its intention to consider introducing a mandatory public tender offer system (by amending the Capital Markets Act) as a means to defend management rights. The mandatory public tender offer system requires a shareholder who acquires a certain threshold of shares in a listed company and becomes a major shareholder to make a public offer for the remaining shares. Kim Namgeun, a member of the KOSPI 5000 Special Committee, told reporters after the party's policy meeting on the 24th, "The primary purpose of treasury stock is not to defend management rights but to implement shareholder return policies," and added, "We plan to follow up with legislation such as the mandatory public tender offer system as a management rights defense policy." Poison pill (stock purchase rights), golden shares, and dual-class shares, which are suggested by the business community, are reportedly not under consideration by the Democratic Party.
The Democratic Party is considering a plan that would require a public tender offer for all remaining shares (100% mandatory public tender offer). However, in this case, mergers and acquisitions (M&A) could become difficult, so a reasonable threshold is being considered. For reference, the previous administration pushed for a plan to mandate public tender offers up to the management control threshold of 50% plus one share. A member of the KOSPI 5000 Special Committee stated, "Since M&A must be possible to some extent, a compromise will likely be found at a middle ground."
However, this too faces challenges, as the chairperson of the National Assembly's Political Affairs Committee, which has jurisdiction over the matter, is a member of the People Power Party, making it difficult for the Democratic Party to accelerate the process. At the first subcommittee meeting for bill review of the Political Affairs Committee held on the 24th, the bill proposed by Assemblyman Lee Jeongmoon was tabled but no conclusion was reached. The bill by Assemblyman Lee Jeongmoon would require a public tender offer for all remaining shares if a particular shareholder acquires 25% or more of the total shares.
Experts: "Rational and Sophisticated Legislation Needed"
Experts emphasize the need for rational and sophisticated legislation. Lee Junseo, a professor of business administration at Dongguk University, said regarding the mandatory public tender offer system, "Since some people may incur losses, the system is necessary," but added, "A plan requiring the purchase of all remaining shares (100% public tender offer) seems excessive, so a more reasonable plan is needed."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Regarding the abolition and alternative legislation for the breach of trust offense, a law school professor who requested anonymity stated, "The breach of trust offense applies not only to managers but also to employees," and added, "While it is desirable not to hold managers liable based on the principle of business judgment, if the offense is entirely abolished, there would be no way to punish employees for breach of trust." The professor further stated, "It would suffice to include a legal provision stating that if a manager's decision was reasonable, they would not be held liable even if the outcome was unfavorable."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.