Nearly Half of 238 Budget Committee Reviews Deferred
Sensitive Items Include AI Projects and Special Activity Funds
Experts Urge Earlier Start to Budget Review Process

Although the National Assembly's review of next year's budget bill is proceeding faster than expected, chronic issues have been repeated once again. The problems of deferred budgets and the so-called 'Sosowi' (Small Subcommittee) have resurfaced. The Sosowi is an informal consultative body composed of a small number of members, including the chairperson of the Special Committee on Budget and Accounts, the ruling and opposition party secretaries, and the Vice Minister of Economy and Finance, which adjusts the budget bill when there are significant differences between the parties. The process is conducted behind closed doors, leading to criticism that it is a secretive backroom negotiation. This year, nearly half of the ten projects reviewed by the subcommittee were deferred and passed on to the Sosowi.


According to the National Assembly on the 25th, the ruling and opposition parties completed the official budget review, which is recorded in the minutes, on November 21. Starting from November 25, the Sosowi, which leaves no official record or minutes, will begin its closed-door deliberations.

Although heated debates between the parties are a recurring feature of budget reviews every year, this year's process concluded relatively smoothly. Initially, the Special Committee on Budget and Accounts planned to hold the Budget Adjustment Subcommittee (hereafter referred to as the subcommittee) sessions for six days, but the schedule was completed within five days. The subcommittee typically conducts a reduction review based on the results of the standing committees, filtering out unnecessary, excessively allocated, or problematic budget items from next year's budget. Based on the results of this review, an increase review is then conducted.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The problem with this year's budget review is that a significant number of projects were classified as deferred. According to an analysis by The Asia Business Daily based on National Assembly records, 114 out of 238 cases (47.9%) reviewed by the Special Committee on Budget and Accounts were deferred. Due to the tight schedule and the large number of items to be reviewed, contentious issues were classified as deferred with the intention of revisiting them later. These deferred projects are supposed to undergo another round of subcommittee review, but instead, they were all transferred to the unofficial Sosowi without further discussion. Given the nature of budget reviews, a final agreement between the ruling and opposition parties is necessary, but deferrals were excessively used without any attempt at compromise or persuasion.


This stands in contrast to last year. Despite the worst political situation that nearly led to martial law, the subcommittee met ten times and at least went through the motions of an increase review. However, this year, a large number of projects were simply deferred.


This year, in particular, projects related to artificial intelligence (AI) became major deferred items due to concerns about 'duplicate investment' and 'AI-washing' (merely labeling existing projects as AI). The overlap of projects and the tendency to simply add AI to existing projects as a justification for budget allocation were cited as reasons. In addition, other sensitive budgets, such as special activity expenses for the Presidential Office, were also deferred one after another. Noh Jongmyon, a Democratic Party lawmaker who participated in the subcommittee, said, "When lawmakers from both parties gather to deliberate, the principle should be to reach an agreement whenever possible. If deferral becomes the norm, the very purpose of the meeting will be questioned," adding, "I cannot understand why so many items are being deferred like this."



[Budget Insights] "Most Items Deferred"... Half of Subcommittee Budget Reviews Classified as 'Deferred' View original image

Lee Sangmin, Senior Research Fellow at the Fiscal Reform Institute, commented, "It seems that the number of deferred cases has increased significantly this year." He criticized, "Projects deferred in the subcommittee should be thoroughly reviewed two or three times, but instead, they are being handed over to a non-statutory, closed-door negotiation table between the parties." He added, "The only way to prevent the collusion-like Sosowi process is to move up the start of the budget review, which currently begins in November. The only solution is to bring forward the budget review to immediately after the September National Assembly session and also advance the schedule for the National Assembly audit."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing