Concerns Over 'Lack of Practicality' and 'Labor Commission Overload' in Government Plan [Will the Yellow Envelope Act Be Effectively Implemented?] ①
The government has proposed three criteria for separating bargaining units among subcontractor unions under the Yellow Envelope Act (the amendment to Articles 2 and 3 of the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act), which is scheduled to take effect in March next year: separation by individual subcontractors, separation by similar job functions among subcontractors, and separation of all subcontractor unions as a group. Both labor and management are expressing strong opposition. From the companies' perspective, they believe that the current mechanism of unifying bargaining channels, which has been a premise of the multiple union system, will effectively be rendered powerless. On the other hand, unions argue that the bargaining power of subcontracted workers may actually be weakened. They claim that requiring subcontracted workers to go through procedures such as bargaining unit separation and unification before negotiating with the primary employer could further escalate workplace conflicts.
On the 24th, Minister of Employment and Labor Kim Younghoon emphasized regarding the revised enforcement decree of the Trade Union Act, "This is the first step in improving the structure that has prevented subcontracted workers from negotiating with the primary employer who determines their working conditions," adding, "While ensuring maximum autonomy for labor and management, we have established an institutional foundation to secure the practical bargaining rights of subcontractor unions in line with the purpose of the amended law."
The core of the revised enforcement decree is that it institutionally reflects the different interests and bargaining scopes of primary and subcontractor unions. The most significant change is that if voluntary agreement between unions is not reached, the Labor Relations Commission can decide on the separation of bargaining units. In the future, even within a single workplace, unions can be organized into separate bargaining units according to the nature of the work, working conditions, and employment types, rather than being grouped into a single bargaining channel. It is natural that the bargaining units of the primary union and various subcontractor unions will be separated in many respects. The main issue is how to handle bargaining units among the hundreds or thousands of subcontractor unions. The government has presented three main options: each subcontractor union bargaining independently, grouping subcontractor unions with similar conditions into a single bargaining unit, or consolidating all subcontractor unions into one unified bargaining channel.
"Unifying Bargaining Channels for Subcontractor Unions Is a Pipe Dream"
Both labor and management point out that the biggest problem with the newly announced enforcement decree is that it effectively creates a structure where the primary employer and subcontractors each have their own separate bargaining systems. The current manual for multiple unions introduced the unification of bargaining channels to "ensure uniformity of working conditions and prevent excessive competition among unions." Therefore, separation of bargaining units has been recognized only as a very narrow "exception" to unification. However, the new amendment is designed with "separation" as the default, which is at odds with the existing framework. The amendment maintains the unification system but creates an abnormal structure where only subcontractor bargaining is conducted separately.
It is also not easy to unify the bargaining channels of all subcontractor unions according to the government manual. This is because each subcontractor has different labor costs, working environments, risk levels, and contract structures. As a result, the burden on primary companies is bound to increase, as the number of bargaining entities could become excessive. According to the manual, if working conditions, employment types, or bargaining practices differ, the Labor Relations Commission can approve separation, and it is expected that most subcontractor unions will meet these criteria, leading to a surge in "separation applications."
There is also the possibility of conflicts between agreements among subcontractor unions. If collective agreements for separated units clash, there is no clear standard for which agreement should take precedence. This is why the labor community is concerned that individual bargaining by subcontractor unions may exist only in form, with little chance of producing substantial results.
Consequently, the rapidly increasing workload of the central and local Labor Relations Commissions is also an immediate concern. The Labor Relations Commission will play a key role not only in separating bargaining units for subcontractor unions but also in determining prerequisites such as whether the primary employer has substantial control. There is also a possibility that a "Committee for Supporting Employer Determination" (tentative name) may be established under its umbrella to resolve various labor-management conflicts arising before and after bargaining.
As workplace concerns suggest, if union bargaining requests surge, related work is likely to be delayed. Furthermore, the Labor Relations Commission has already been requesting additional staff for years due to the increasing number of labor disputes. An industry representative predicted, "If unions request bargaining in the future, companies will have no choice but to consult the government case by case. If work processing is delayed, workplace confusion will only worsen."
The government is also well aware of these issues. An official from the Ministry of Labor said, "We recognize the need to expand the functions of the Labor Relations Commission," and added, "We have already requested additional personnel from the Ministry of the Interior and Safety." However, despite the urgent need to increase staffing at the Labor Relations Commission, the relevant discussions have not yet been finalized. Regarding the future scale of additional personnel for the Central Labor Relations Commission, the official said, "We will have to wait for the decision from the Ministry of the Interior and Safety," declining to comment further.
"Concerns Over Proliferation of Minority Unions Within Primary Employers"
The business community is also concerned about the proliferation of minority unions within primary employers. They argue that this could be an even more immediate and practical source of confusion than bargaining demands from subcontractor unions. The key issue is the multi-layered fragmentation within primary employers. Currently, the collective agreement signed by the representative union of the primary employer applies to all members, but if unit separation is allowed, working conditions could differ by job group, occupation, or work type. If production, office, and research staff, as well as day and shift workers, all claim separate bargaining units, multiple bargaining channels could emerge within the primary employer.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
This impact is especially significant in large workplaces. For example, in manufacturing sites where multiple unions coexist, if minority unions affiliated with the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions demand independent bargaining units, the existing representative union-centered bargaining system could collapse. Hwang Yongyeon, Head of Labor Policy at the Korea Employers Federation, said, "For nearly 15 years since multiple unions were allowed, the key mechanism maintaining the one company, one bargaining, one collective agreement system has been the unification of bargaining channels. The new enforcement decree has changed the structure so that if minority unions within the primary employer demand separation of bargaining units, it will be difficult to refuse. While the government says such situations won't occur, companies already see this as a very real risk."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.