Calls to Hold Rates Led by Hawks,
But Labor Market Shock Now Seen as Greater Risk Than Inflation
Markets Also Betting on a Rate Cut Next Month

Christopher Waller, Federal Reserve Board Governor. Photo by Reuters Yonhap News

Christopher Waller, Federal Reserve Board Governor. Photo by Reuters Yonhap News

View original image

As the U.S. Federal Reserve’s monetary policy meeting in December approaches, internal opinions have become divided. While hawkish members who favor monetary tightening had initially dominated with calls to keep rates unchanged, a counterargument has emerged, suggesting that the shock to the labor market could be more significant than concerns over inflation. Some observers are even speculating that, for the first time in Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) history, a “6 to 6” tie vote could occur.


On November 24 (local time), Federal Reserve Board Governor Christopher Waller stated in an interview with Fox News, “My main concern is with the labor market, which relates to our dual mandate,” adding, “That’s why I support a rate cut at the next meeting.”


He explained that with the U.S. labor market currently weak, inflation is not the primary issue. “I still do not expect the employment market to rebound in the coming weeks,” he said, adding, “The September employment figures are likely to be revised downward, and the fact that these numbers are concentrated in specific sectors is not a good sign.”


On the same day, Mary Daly, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, also expressed support for a rate cut in December in an interview with The Wall Street Journal. She explained that labor market weakness poses a greater risk than concerns over inflation.


President Daly had taken a cautious stance in mid-November, saying it was “premature” to make a decision, but has since shifted her position. Although she does not have voting rights this year or next, she is considered highly influential. The significance of her remarks is heightened by the fact that she has often aligned with Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell.


Initially, the market had expected rates to remain unchanged in December. The weakening of the U.S. stock market in November was largely attributed to the waning expectation of a December rate cut, alongside concerns about an artificial intelligence (AI) bubble. In particular, Chair Powell calmed markets after the October rate cut by stating, “A rate cut in December is not a foregone conclusion.” The minutes from the October FOMC meeting, released afterward, also indicated that many members supported holding rates steady in December, reinforcing this outlook.


However, on November 21, John Williams, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, signaled the possibility of a December rate cut by stating, “I see the potential for rates to be lowered in the near future.” The market sentiment shifted dramatically after this, as President Williams holds a voting right at the meeting.


Some analysts are now suggesting that the upcoming FOMC meeting could result in a 6-to-6 tie. In a report on November 23, Capital Economics warned, “If this happens, the situation will become very complicated.”


Currently, among the Fed governors, the hawkish members include Governor Michael Barr, Governor Philip Jefferson, and the four regional Fed presidents with voting rights this year: Susan Collins, Austan Goolsbee, Alberto Musalem, and Jeffrey Schmid, totaling six. Conversely, the dovish Fed governors are Michelle Bowman, Fed Governor Stephen Miran, and Waller, making three. If President Williams joins them, the dovish side would have four, resulting in a 6:4 split.


The key factor is Chair Powell’s position. Capital Economics analyzed, “President Williams and Chair Powell often share the same views, and Governor Lisa Cook usually votes in line with Chair Powell.” According to this scenario, a 6-to-6 tie could occur.


The Fed is not known to have ever recorded a tie vote in an FOMC meeting. Robert Eisenbeis, former research director at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, explained in an interview with Fortune earlier this year, “If there is a tie, the benchmark rate remains at its current level, as there is no rule to overturn a tie vote, and the chair cannot forcibly change it.” He added that it is also unclear whether a revote would be held at the same meeting or postponed to the next one.


The gap in economic indicators caused by the U.S. government shutdown (temporary work stoppage) is another factor complicating the Fed’s decision. The October employment and inflation data were entirely canceled, and the November data will not be released until after the FOMC meeting scheduled for December 9-10. As a result, the Fed is in a “blind spot,” having to make rate decisions based on alternative indicators such as private employment, unemployment claims, and the Beige Book, according to USA Today.


For now, the market appears to be betting on a December rate cut. According to the CME FedWatch Tool, the federal funds futures market is pricing in an 85.1% probability of a 25 basis point (1bp = 0.01 percentage point) rate cut in December, up from 71.0% at the previous day’s close.



Overnight, U.S. stock markets also closed higher, reflecting policy expectations. The blue-chip Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 0.44% from the previous session, the large-cap S&P 500 Index climbed over 1%, and the tech-heavy Nasdaq Index surged more than 2%. Notably, a renewed buying spree in AI-related stocks, led by Google’s parent company Alphabet, drove a significant rebound in the markets.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing