[World+]The Global Order That Will Be Shaken After the Ukraine Peace Agreement
US Formalizes NATO Non-Admission, Offers EU as Alternative
Security Guarantees in Doubt Due to Military Limitations
Recognition of Russian-Occupied Territories and Sanctions Relief Spark Controversy
Concerns Persist Over US Prioritizing Its
The Ukraine war is once again rapidly moving toward a possible conclusion. The United States has presented Ukraine with a draft peace agreement consisting of 28 articles and has demanded a response by November 27. In response, European leaders have stated that further discussions are necessary, and U.S. President Donald Trump has also indicated that the proposed terms are subject to adjustment. On November 23, national security officials from France, the United Kingdom, and Germany met in Geneva, Switzerland, to discuss the matter, with U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio also in attendance. Although the agreement was initially believed to have been proposed by Russia to the United States, it was later revealed that the U.S. drafted it, and U.S. officials acknowledged that it was based on Russian input.
The contents of the proposal include a range of measures, including the cessation of hostilities. The draft reaffirms Ukraine's sovereignty and aims to eliminate the possibility of further conflict by establishing a comprehensive non-aggression pact among Ukraine, Russia, and Europe. To this end, Russia is demanding that it will not invade neighboring countries and that the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) will not expand further.
The United States has emphasized that if either side undertakes additional military action, the agreement will become void. While reaffirming sovereignty may seem obvious, it is a significant step forward given Russia's previous refusal to recognize Ukraine. However, since the draft includes Russia's demand to prohibit NATO expansion, controversy over this issue appears inevitable.
For Ukraine, it is essential to include measures to prevent another Russian invasion. According to the draft, Ukraine would be provided with reliable security guarantees, but the size of its military would be limited to 600,000 troops, and it would be required to enshrine in its constitution that it will not join NATO. NATO, in turn, would be required to amend its regulations to formally exclude Ukraine from membership.
Additionally, NATO forces would not be stationed in Ukraine, and European countries' fighter jets would be based in Poland. Instead, Ukraine would be allowed to join the European Union (EU), and during the accession process, it would be granted preferential access to the European market. While the draft fundamentally blocks Ukraine's NATO membership and offers EU accession as an alternative, it also prohibits the stationing of NATO forces in Ukraine, raising questions about the effectiveness of the proposed security guarantees. By positioning European fighter jets in Poland, the United States is also indirectly emphasizing that it will not intervene in future conflicts between the two sides.
On the 25th (local time), protesters held a nighttime rally in front of the United States Embassy in Prague, Czech Republic. They voiced opposition to the peace plan for the Ukraine war proposed by the Trump administration, shouting, "No to the 2025 version of Munich. Do not sell out Ukraine." Prague - Reuters / Yonhap News Agency
View original imageRegarding Ukraine's reconstruction, the draft calls for the establishment of a Ukraine Development Fund to invest in rapidly growing sectors such as artificial intelligence (AI) and data centers, as well as infrastructure, mineral, and natural resource development, with the World Bank (WB) providing a special financial package. The funding for this would include the use of Russian assets currently frozen by Western countries. Specifically, $100 billion in frozen assets would be allocated for reconstruction, with Europe contributing an additional $100 billion. In return, the United States would claim 50% of the profits generated from the $100 billion in frozen assets, while the remaining frozen funds would be invested in a joint investment entity operated by the United States and Russia to carry out joint projects. For the United States, this structure allows it to support Ukraine's reconstruction using Russian funds rather than its own, while also profiting from the process.
In exchange for relinquishing claims to the frozen assets, Russia would receive recognition of its territorial gains. This includes formal recognition of Crimea and the entire Donbas region as Russian territory. The currently contested Donetsk region would be recognized as Russian territory but designated as a demilitarized zone. The lifting of sanctions against Russia would be discussed and implemented in stages, and Russia would be invited to rejoin the Group of Eight (G8). While Russia would forgo its frozen funds, it would gain international recognition of all territories it has occupied since the forcible annexation of Crimea in 2014. Furthermore, the draft stipulates that there would be no prosecutions or accusations regarding actions taken during the war, effectively granting Russia amnesty for war crimes.
Overall, the peace plan reflects Russia's intentions and is structured in its favor. It recognizes the territories Russia has occupied, blocks NATO expansion, and prevents Ukraine from joining NATO, thereby allowing Russia the possibility to invade Ukraine again in the future. While Russia welcomed the draft as a foundation for resolving the conflict, it is clear that the terms are difficult for Ukraine and Europe to accept. For the Ukrainian people, who have made enormous sacrifices, the losses are clear, but the guarantees for the future are ambiguous, making it hard to accept such a proposal. In particular, the draft requires Ukraine to hold a presidential election within 100 days of the ceasefire, a condition that President Volodymyr Zelensky is unlikely to accept.
Germany and France have agreed that the current proposal is excessively disadvantageous to Ukraine and have emphasized that support for Ukraine is crucial to European security. In a national address, President Zelensky stated that he would continue to fight for the dignity and freedom of the Ukrainian people but acknowledged that the country faces difficult choices. He stressed the need for unity and consensus to avoid losing either national dignity or key partners.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The outcome of the negotiations will determine whether the Ukraine war continues, but it is clear that the United States will not make further active efforts to guarantee the security of other countries. It has also become evident that economic interests now take precedence over principles and justifications. Depending on the outcome of the Ukraine peace negotiations, the global order is likely to be shaken once again.
Choi Junyoung, Senior Expert at Yulchon LLC (Global Law & Policy)
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.