"Retirement Age Extension-Type Wage Peak System Deemed Reasonable"
First and Second Instance Courts: "Considering Total Compensation Increase,
No Definite Damages, No Age Discrimination"
Appellate Court Maintains Same Reasoning
Supreme Court D

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

The Supreme Court has dismissed, without a full hearing, a lawsuit filed by Korean Air employees seeking damages over the company’s retirement age extension wage peak system, known as the "impeaje." The lower court’s decision was upheld, confirming that the policy of extending the retirement age from 56 to 60 while gradually reducing wages from age 56 was based on reasonable grounds and did not constitute age discrimination.


According to the legal community on November 24, the Supreme Court’s Third Division (Presiding Justice Oh Seokjun) ruled on September 25 that the appeal by 32 Korean Air employees in their damages lawsuit against the company did not meet the grounds stipulated in Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the Act on Special Cases Concerning Appellate Procedure. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal immediately without a substantive review, effectively confirming the lower court’s ruling as final without further deliberation.


This case began in 2016, following the implementation of legislation mandating a retirement age of 60. In response, Korean Air extended the retirement age from 56 to 60 but introduced the impeaje in agreement with the labor union to prevent a sharp increase in total labor costs. According to the court ruling, Korean Air and the union agreed that employees would receive 90% of their existing salary at age 56, 81% at 57, 72.9% at 58, and 65.61% at 59, with employment guaranteed until retirement. This measure was finalized at the end of 2015 through labor-management negotiations and adjustments, taking into account the seniority-based wage structure characteristic of the airline industry.

[Exclusive] Supreme Court Dismisses Korean Air Retirement Age Extension-Type Wage Peak System Damages Lawsuit View original image

On the other hand, the employees who filed the lawsuit argued that the company had used the legally mandated retirement age extension as a pretext to effectively reduce wages. The plaintiffs claimed that the retirement age extension was due to the law, and that the company’s approach-treating "retirement age extension = wage reduction" as an automatic linkage-constituted discriminatory wage cuts based on age. They sought damages, stating that this resulted in losses (including reduced wages and severance pay) of between 40 million and 70 million won per person. The plaintiffs particularly emphasized that the logic of cutting wages simply because the retirement age was extended was neither fair nor reasonable under labor law.


However, both the first and second instance courts sided with Korean Air. In the first trial, delivered on August 23 last year, the court found that "the impeaje was a necessary measure to mitigate the significant increase in labor costs resulting from the retirement age extension, and the legitimacy of its purpose is recognized." The court also stated, "Given the increase in total length of service and the corresponding rise in total compensation due to the extension of the retirement age from 56 to 60, it cannot be concluded that the wage adjustment resulted in actual losses." The court reviewed the plaintiffs’ claims regarding reduced wages and severance pay (up to 70 million won) but rejected them, stating that "the reduced portion cannot be considered in isolation." Ultimately, the first trial ruled against all plaintiffs.


The plaintiffs’ appeal was also dismissed in the second trial, which was decided on May 30 this year. The appellate court held that "the grounds for appeal are identical to those raised in the first trial" and fully upheld the lower court’s key findings. The appellate court maintained the first-instance conclusion that "the impeaje does not constitute age discrimination and is a measure based on reasonable grounds," and the Supreme Court finalized the case by dismissing the appeal without a hearing. The lower court’s judgment that "the impeaje is a reasonable measure" was thus accepted as final.



Given that many companies and public institutions are currently implementing retirement age extension-type impeaje systems, this case is expected to serve as a significant precedent for similar lawsuits in the future. In particular, as bills are being promoted to further extend the current retirement age of 60 to 63 or 65, this Supreme Court ruling is likely to influence corporate policies regarding retirement age extension wage peak systems going forward. Attorney Jo Inseon of YK Law Firm commented, "While we need to monitor institutional changes surrounding the current policy trend of legal retirement age extension, the discussion will likely proceed in tandem with the impeaje debate. If the retirement age is extended to 63 or 65, it is likely that more companies will adopt the impeaje system."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing