No Cumulative Regulations Based on Assets or Revenue in the US, UK, Germany, or Japan
343 Stepwise Regulations in 12 Korean Laws... "Growth Incentives Weakened"

An analysis has found that so-called differentiated regulations based on corporate size-where additional regulations are imposed as a company's assets or revenue increase-are applied extensively only in South Korea among major countries.


It has been pointed out that such differentiated regulations act as a growth penalty, reducing the incentive for companies to expand, and there is a growing call for adjustments to these related systems.


According to the "Status and Implications of Corporate Size-Based Regulations in Major Countries" report released on the 23rd by the Korean Chamber of Commerce and Industry and prepared by Professor Kim Youngju’s team at Pusan National University, major advanced economies such as the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, and Japan do not have systems in which regulations are incrementally increased based on asset or revenue size.


These countries structure their regulatory systems according to factors such as whether a company is publicly listed, its legal form and status, and specific activities like disclosure and accounting.


In contrast, South Korea sets regulations based on quantitative indicators such as total assets, sales, and number of employees in various economic laws-including the Commercial Act, the Capital Markets Act, the Fair Trade Act, and the External Audit Act-creating a structure where new obligations are sequentially added as a company grows.


Professor Kim’s team analyzed domestic legislation and found that a total of 343 stepwise regulations are in effect across 12 laws.


In the United States, corporate regulations are not subdivided by size, and there are no separate legal provisions specifically for large corporations. Listed companies must fulfill obligations such as maintaining governance structures and undergoing external audits, while antitrust regulations focus on conduct such as cartels, abuse, and mergers. It was also confirmed that state corporate law systems do not categorize large corporations to impose additional obligations.


Similarly, in the United Kingdom, companies are classified as public or private, but public companies are not further subdivided by size for regulatory purposes.


Professor Kim explained, "In Anglo-American countries, companies are not classified as large, medium, or small for regulatory purposes, nor are large companies subdivided by size to apply cumulative regulations. Regulations are based solely on whether a company is listed and its conduct in the market."


He continued, "In South Korea, business groups are designated based on size, and regulations are continually layered according to asset brackets, with multiple laws such as the Commercial Act and the Fair Trade Act overlapping, resulting in a structural burden on corporate growth."


The report also noted that while Germany’s Commercial Code classifies corporations as small, medium, or large, this is limited to technical standards in accounting areas such as financial statement preparation, disclosure, and auditing.


Japan’s Companies Act defines companies with capital of 500 million yen or more, or debt of 20 billion yen or more, as large companies, but does not further subdivide these companies or impose differentiated regulations based on size.



Lee Jongmyung, Head of the Industrial Innovation Division at the Korean Chamber of Commerce and Industry, stated, "The differentiated policies based on corporate size, introduced during South Korea’s period of rapid economic growth, were intended to curb economic concentration and reduce growth disparities. However, with growth stagnating today, there is a need to reconsider these systems to encourage corporate growth."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing