"Productive Finance Blind Spots in the Startup Ecosystem... Joint Liability and Preemptive Consent Rights Need Reform"
Discussion Forum on "Blind Spots and Development Directions of Productive Finance"
Jointly Hosted by the Korean Entrepreneurship Society and The Asia Business Daily
"One Failure Becomes a Stigma... Korea Discourages Entrepreneurial Ambition"
"Gov
There have been calls to first address the financial blind spots that undermine entrepreneurial motivation in order to achieve sustainable economic growth for the Korean economy. Investment practices that demand excessive joint liability from founders are blocking re-entrepreneurship, and cases where investors' "prior consent rights" prevent follow-up investments are making business growth itself impossible. Given these ongoing issues, there is an urgent need to improve the investment ecosystem in line with the government's policy to strengthen productive finance.
On the 22nd, the Korean Entrepreneurship Society, together with The Asia Business Daily, held a discussion forum at the Seoul Startup Hub Gongdeok under the theme "Blind Spots and Development Directions of Productive Finance: The Scope of Responsibility for Failed Startup CEOs and Overseas Cases," where participants shared these concerns.
During his congratulatory speech, Han Kyu Kim, a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Korea and co-chair of the National Assembly Startup Support Research Group "Unicorn Farm," stated, "For the sustainable growth of the economy, it is crucial to create an environment where entrepreneurs are not afraid of failure and can try again. It is time to build a financial ecosystem that ensures fair responsibility, transparent investment, and the possibility of a second chance. I will do my utmost to carefully review support measures for the startup ecosystem and propose substantive policies."
On the 22nd, participants spoke at the discussion forum titled "Blind Spots and Development Directions of Productive Finance," jointly hosted by the Korean Entrepreneurship Society and The Asia Business Daily. From the left, Kim Seonghun, President of the Korean Venture Investment Law Society (Representative Lawyer at Mission Law Firm), Ha Sanghyun, Director of the Korea Corporate Rehabilitation Management Association (Lawyer at Darae Law Firm), and Kang Hyemi, Representative Lawyer at Byeol Law Firm.
View original imagePut Option Joint Liability..."With a Startup Failure Rate Over 90%, Who Would Dare to Start a Business?"
Seong Hun Kim, President of the Korean Venture Investment Law Society (Representative Lawyer at Mission Law Firm), pointed out structural problems in domestic venture investment during his keynote presentation. He noted, "Various rights, such as 'put options,' which are included in most investment contracts, are ultimately designed to hold founders jointly liable for investments. Productive finance should support new challenges and development through equity investment, sharing both profits and risks. However, in Korea, venture investment is still dominated by a creditor-centered mindset-if you lend money, it must be repaid, and if not, someone must be held responsible."
He also highlighted the abuse of "prior consent rights" by early investors. Kim explained, "There was even a case where an investor filed for an injunction to block follow-up investment due to concerns about equity dilution. In the end, bankruptcy was the only option left for the company." He emphasized, "Instead of giving every investor an individual veto right, we should adopt a 'collective consent' system. In the United States, there is no system granting individual veto rights to investors."
Kim further stated, "Startups have a failure rate of over 90%, so if joint liability is imposed for failures, who would dare to start a business? Unlike the US, domestic venture capital firms are overly conscious of the parent fund and limited partners."
Abuse of Prior Consent Rights Blocks Follow-up Investment..."Prior Consent Rights Should Shift to 'Collective Consent'"
During the main forum, venture experts shared a sense of crisis, emphasizing that without fundamental improvements to the startup ecosystem, sustainable economic growth in Korea would be difficult. Sang Hyun Ha, Director of the Korea Corporate Rehabilitation Management Association (Lawyer at Darae Law Firm), who moderated the discussion, remarked, "In a capitalist society, entrepreneurship and second chances are essential topics that cannot be overlooked. There is a need to establish a clear philosophy on this matter."
Hye Mi Kang, Representative Lawyer at Byeol Law Firm, pointed out, "There are blind spots because there are no joint liability restrictions for new technology finance companies or large corporate investors. We need to apply such restrictions across different types of investors." She added, "The grounds for exercising put options are often too broad, and there are many cases where penalties overlap with other claims. In some cases, founders are required to pay more than twice the invested principal." She urged that the grounds for exercising put options should be limited to intentional or grossly negligent acts by founders.
Sang Hyun Ha, Director of the Korea Corporate Rehabilitation Management Association (Lawyer at Darae Law Firm), explained, "Domestic venture capital firms tend to only seek startups with guaranteed growth, causing a bottleneck where investment funds do not increase. In this situation, founders who receive investments find it difficult to refuse unfavorable terms."
The short-term performance-based evaluation system used by the government and support agencies was also identified as a problem. Woochan Kim, Manager of the Youth Challenge Team at the Korea Institute of Startup & Entrepreneurship Development, said, "There are many policy contradictions where the government encourages entrepreneurship but also demands that startups must not fail. Venture capital, which is designed to take risks, is instead becoming capital that avoids risk."
Kim added, "The government requires annual performance results from startup incubators, accelerators, and venture capital firms, and next year's budgets and incentives depend on these evaluations. Innovation requires time and trial and error, but with a short-term evaluation structure, it is difficult to pursue long-term challenges such as R&D and technology commercialization."
(From left) Woochan Kim, Manager of Youth Challenge Team at the Korea Institute of Startup & Entrepreneurship Development, Minhyung Lee, Head of Policy Research Team at the Korea Venture Business Association, and Siyoung Jo, Head of IB Team at The Asia Business Daily, are exchanging opinions at the forum.
View original imageProposal to Establish Standard Guidelines and Introduce ESG Perspectives
There was consensus on the urgent need to establish standard guidelines for investment contracts. Especially since the investment winter has continued since 2023, participants shared a sense of crisis that sustainable economic growth will be difficult without fundamental improvements to the startup ecosystem.
Moon Hyun Ko, President of the Korean ESG Society, stated, "If many investment companies pursue only profit and shift losses onto startups, the foundation of ESG (environmental, social, and governance) will be undermined. Ultimately, this will worsen companies' ability to raise capital."
Siyoung Jo, Head of the IB Team at The Asia Business Daily, suggested, "As new technology finance companies, asset management firms, and private equity funds are also investing heavily in ventures, the government and relevant agencies should establish standard guidelines to coordinate the market. Financial holding companies are also competitively promoting productive finance. It would be effective for them to voluntarily participate in campaigns to develop the venture investment ecosystem."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Minhyung Lee, Head of the Policy Research Team at the Korea Venture Business Association, diagnosed, "Although the venture ecosystem has been around for 30 years, there is still a lack of a virtuous cycle of investment, exit, and re-entrepreneurship."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.