Supreme Court: Prior Consent from Data Subject
No Grounds for Leakage Charge... First Explicit Ruling
Names, Building, and Unit Numbers Posted in Group Chat
Residents: "We Consented... This Is Not a Leak"

"Posting Names and Unit Numbers in Group Chat Not a Leak if Residents Consented" ? Supreme Court Overturns Appellate Ruling View original image

The Supreme Court has overturned a lower court ruling and remanded the case for retrial, stating that if prior consent from the data subject was obtained, one cannot be punished for the offense of disclosing personal information. This marks the first time the Supreme Court has clearly ruled that prior consent precludes punishment for the disclosure of personal information.


According to the legal community on November 21, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Lee Sukyeon) overturned the previous verdict, which had fined administrative scrivener A 300,000 won for violating the Personal Information Protection Act, and sent the case back for retrial.


An administrative scrivener collected the real names, building numbers, and apartment numbers of approximately 280 residents of an apartment complex in Gangnam-gu, Seoul, after being authorized by them to discuss compensation for damages caused by nearby Hyundai Engineering & Construction works. However, the scrivener was prosecuted for violating Article 59, Item 2 of the Personal Information Protection Act, accused of posting each resident's real name, building, and apartment number in a KakaoTalk group chat created to communicate with the residents.


The first trial ruled that the postings exceeded the scope of work-related purposes and found the defendant partially guilty, imposing a fine of 500,000 won. The second trial also imposed a fine of 300,000 won.


However, the Supreme Court reached a different conclusion. Taking into account the wording of the former Personal Information Protection Act Article 59, Item 2 and Article 71, Item 5, as well as the right of informational self-determination and the purpose of the law, the Supreme Court ruled, "If the data subject has given prior consent, this cannot be punished as a disclosure of personal information."



The court particularly emphasized that the residents participating in the group chat had agreed to the use of their names, building, and apartment numbers in the chat room. In fact, during the previous trial, the residents submitted statements indicating, "We do not believe our personal information was disclosed," and "We were not even aware of the complaint." The court also pointed out that the complaint was filed solely by the apartment management office director, not by the residents, and that even if the defendant may have had some personal motives, the existence of consent itself cannot be denied. The Supreme Court concluded that the lower court misunderstood the requirements for the offense of disclosing personal information and failed to conduct the necessary review, and thus ordered a retrial.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing