Unpaid Suspension After Project Withdrawal, Then Notice of Dismissal
Court: "Unilateral Termination of Employment Is Unlawful"

A court has ruled that an IT company's decision to dismiss a full-time employee, citing industry practice of employees leaving after project completion, constitutes unfair dismissal.

Company Claimed "Leaving After Project Ends Is IT Industry Practice"... Court Rules "Unfair Dismissal" View original image

According to the legal community on November 24, the 12th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court, presided over by Chief Judge Kang Jae-won, recently ruled in favor of the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by Mr. A against the Chairman of the Central Labor Relations Commission, seeking to overturn a retrial decision that denied relief for unfair dismissal.


Mr. A joined IT company B in 2023 and was assigned to a specific project. Subsequently, on February 6 of last year, the company notified Mr. A that he would be withdrawn from the project and that they would consider assigning him to another business unit or project. On February 14, the company further informed him that "the new project assignment will be determined between March 20 and April 8, so you will be placed on suspension until then."


However, in March, the company unilaterally notified Mr. A that he would be leaving the company, stating, "It has been decided that you will resign while on suspension." Mr. A filed for relief from unfair dismissal with both the Seoul Regional Labor Relations Commission and the Central Labor Relations Commission, but both agencies dismissed his claim, stating that it was not a dismissal but a resignation resulting from project withdrawal.


The court, however, reached a different conclusion. The bench pointed out, "There is no evidence to support the company's claim that Mr. A expressed an intention to resign voluntarily on February 6." According to call recordings and other evidence from that time, it was actually the company that first proposed project withdrawal and reassignment, and both parties continued discussions on the premise of maintaining the employment relationship.


The court also did not accept the company's claim of a 'resignation agreement.' The bench cited the fact that Mr. A refused to resign during the suspension process and inquired about the possibility of taking a leave of absence, as well as the company's statement that "resignation would be the norm, but we will reconsider," as grounds for finding it difficult to conclude that a resignation agreement existed.


Furthermore, the court rejected company B's argument that "it is industry practice in the IT sector for employment to end when a project is completed." The contract between the two parties was a standard full-time employment contract with no fixed term, and the court found that no such implied condition could be assumed.



The bench stated, "Company B's sudden notification to the plaintiff of the decision to terminate employment constitutes a dismissal, as it was a unilateral termination of the employment relationship by the employer regardless of the employee's intention," and ruled, "The retrial decision in this case, which found that the participant's dismissal of the plaintiff did not constitute unfair dismissal, is unlawful."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing