[M&A All About] Will Attempts at 'Split Listings' Stop?... Changes After the Commercial Act Amendment
"Korea's Dual Listing Rate Is 360 Times Higher Than That of the US"
Atmosphere of Restraint on Dual Listings Forms After Commercial Act Amendments
Ban on Treasury Stock Allocation in Spin-Offs... Spin-Off Practices Also Evolving
This is what President Lee Jaemyung said when he visited the Korea Exchange as his first external event just a week after his inauguration in June. At the time, President Lee remarked, "It has now become difficult to make long-term investments in blue-chip stocks," and added, "I can't even recommend investing in the Korean stock market to those around me."
Since then, the Korean stock market has moved at a breakneck pace. Along with liquidity supply, efforts to improve corporate governance, such as amendments to the Commercial Act, have taken place, and the KOSPI index even surpassed the 4,200 mark for the first time in history. However, the controversy over dual listings, also known as 'split listings,' continues to resurface. In particular, the debate reignited recently when the LS Group pushed ahead with the listing of Essex Solutions.
Korea's Dual Listing Ratio at 18%... 360 Times Higher Than the US
Dual listing refers to the process where a listed company spins off its most profitable 'core' business unit and lists it separately, or lists an unlisted subsidiary that was previously consolidated. Typically, when only the parent company is listed, the value of the subsidiary is reflected in the parent's share price. However, if the subsidiary is listed separately, it often leads to a decline in the parent company's share price.
According to NH Investment & Securities, as of early last month, the dual listing ratio in the Korean stock market stood at about 18%, which is 360 times higher than that of the United States (0.05%). This figure is overwhelmingly high compared to Japan (4.02%), China (2.42%), and Taiwan (2.71%). Na Jeonghwan, a researcher at NH Investment & Securities, explained, "In the US, dual listings are so rare that they exist only for a few companies held by Berkshire Hathaway," and added, "If you consider the chain structure of parent companies, subsidiaries, and sub-subsidiaries in Korea, the actual ratio is likely even higher."
However, with the recent trend of Commercial Act amendments, attempts at dual listings have somewhat subsided. The government and the ruling party have introduced changes such as expanding directors' fiduciary duties (from the company alone to the company and its shareholders) and implementing cumulative voting through two amendments to the Commercial Act this year. As a result, some companies have withdrawn their spin-off plans in the face of opposition from minority shareholders. Pharmaresearch canceled its plan for a spin-off to transition to a holding company structure, and Hanamicron and Binggrae also abandoned their spin-off plans for the same reason.
Lee Nayea, a researcher at Korea Investment & Securities, stated, "With the amendment of directors' fiduciary duties, unilateral decision-making centered on controlling shareholders will change in situations where the interests of general and controlling shareholders may conflict," and emphasized, "Shareholder oversight will be strengthened in areas such as company spin-offs, treasury stock transactions, M&A, and asset transfers."
Kim Hojung, a researcher at Yuanta Securities, commented, "With the amendment of the Commercial Act, it will be difficult to transition to a holding company structure through the same type of spin-offs as in the past," and explained, "This method of spin-off has allowed major shareholders to strengthen their control over holding companies through in-kind contributions, while entrenching simultaneous listings of parent and subsidiary companies, which has led to a discount in corporate value."
"Expansion of Directors' Fiduciary Duties Will Strengthen Shareholder Oversight Related to Dual Listings"
In fact, the share prices of companies that resolved dual listings have risen significantly. The merger of Celltrion and Celltrion Healthcare, the integration of Meritz Financial, Meritz Securities, and Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance, and the merger of HD Hyundai Heavy Industries and HD Hyundai Mipo are cited as successful cases. Previously, immediately after announcing spin-off plans, Hanamicron's share price fell by 13.8% and Pharmaresearch's by 17.1%, but after withdrawing these plans, their shares surged by 13.2% and 13.7%, respectively.
As a result, attempts by some companies to spin off subsidiaries are facing even greater criticism. A prime example is LS Group's recent request for a preliminary KOSPI listing review for its affiliate, Essex Solutions. Essex Solutions is a subsidiary specializing in special windings for transformers, and over the past four years, it has recorded average annual growth rates of 11% in North America and 8% in Europe. Last year, it achieved sales of approximately 129 million dollars (about 190 billion won).
This is the first attempt at a dual listing by a major conglomerate since the amendment to the Commercial Act expanding directors' fiduciary duties passed the National Assembly in July. LS Group Chairman Koo Ja-eun sparked controversy in March when, in response to the debate over subsidiary dual listings, he said, "If you think it's a problem, just don't buy the stock." Minority shareholders have criticized this move as "an act that directly contradicts the current government's corporate value-up initiative," and said, "To express our firm opposition, we launched a petition campaign to the Korea Exchange."
LS maintains that Essex Solutions needs to go public because it can independently raise large-scale capital expenditure (CAPEX) funds and contribute the resulting profits to consolidated performance. The Korea Exchange plans to conduct a preliminary review of Essex Solutions' listing until February 10 next year. Due to the dual listing controversy, a more rigorous review process is expected.
Ban on Allocating New Shares to Treasury Stock... Spin-Offs Also Evolving
Investors are also paying attention to the positive effects of the 'ban on allocating new shares to treasury stock' system related to spin-offs. Since the amendment to the Enforcement Decree of the Capital Markets Act was implemented at the end of last year, listed companies have been prohibited from allocating new shares to their own treasury stock during spin-offs. This has prevented major shareholders from strengthening their control and enhanced the protection of general shareholders.
Samsung Biologics is a good example. When it spun off its CDMO (contract development and manufacturing organization) and new drug development businesses into Samsung Biologics and Samsung Episholding, it was able to clarify the intrinsic value of each business without allocating new shares to treasury stock. Researcher Na Jeonghwan assessed, "By restricting major shareholders from strengthening their control through treasury stock and enhancing the original shareholder return function, this will contribute to improving corporate governance."
He also stated, "For the most ideal valuation (stock price relative to corporate value) recovery in the domestic stock market, it is necessary to improve governance, especially by eliminating dual listings through voluntary mergers by companies," and added, "As investors' interest in dual listings has recently increased, events related to resolving dual listings are leading to positive stock price trends."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Ultimately, because dual listings are directly linked to the credibility of Korea's capital market beyond individual corporate issues, the choices made by both companies and the market will determine the direction of future value-up initiatives.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.