Differences in Perspectives Between Executives and Employees Revealed by Survey
Executives Focus on Work Utilization, Employees Worry About Job Loss

Editor's Note[JjinBeat] is an abbreviation for 'Jung Hyun-jin's Business Trends' as well as 'genuine business trends,' and it is a section that highlights trends in changes to work. The 'Office Shift' segment within JjinBeat takes a close look at the transformations that have taken place in office environments since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, aiming to establish a foundation for finding the answer to forms of work through the experiments we have undertaken together. This content will reach you every Saturday or Sunday. After 40 installments, it is planned to be published as a book.
[Real Beat] Productivity Up with AI, but... Boss from Hwaseong, Employee from Geumseong [Office Shift] (33) View original image

"The explosive popularity of generative artificial intelligence (AI), such as ChatGPT, is creating a new order for business and society. There is a significant perception gap between top management and frontline staff regarding AI, and companies need to work on narrowing this gap."


Boston Consulting Group (BCG) gave this advice in a report released last month titled "What Do People Say About AI Used in the Workplace?" It is never easy for corporate leaders and frontline employees to be of one mind, given the differences in their authority and perspectives. The same challenge exists when it comes to utilizing AI in the workplace.

Reuters Yonhap News

Reuters Yonhap News

View original image

There is a growing expectation that the generative AI, which has shaken the world in 2023, will transform all aspects of work. But its effects and impact on the economy remain unclear. Especially in terms of employment, assessments indicate that discussion is still in the early stages. While there is widespread concern that AI will take away jobs, there is also hope that it will instead create new jobs—contradictory outlooks co-exist.


In this state of confusion, top management must decide how to implement AI into the workplace, while employees need to learn new technology and adapt it to their current roles, adjusting how they work. As work undergoes significant transformation, effective communication between both sides is essential for a relatively stable adoption of new technologies on site. With AI rapidly entering the workplace, right now is a crucial time to understand what each side is thinking.


Several surveys on AI and the workplace released recently offer a look into the thoughts of company presidents—i.e., executives—and frontline staff.

◆ Management and Employees Agree on "Boosting Productivity"

“Boosting productivity with AI” is the area where companies are currently focusing their energy. Both top management and frontline employees share this view regarding AI.


In a survey conducted by Microsoft (MS) this March, the top priority cited by executives regarding AI was "improving employee productivity" (31%, multiple responses allowed). The second highest was "helping employees with tedious tasks" (29%), and the fourth was "eliminating unnecessary time spent on less important tasks" (25%)—all pointing to their intent to use AI mainly for productivity gains.


In the same survey, 70% of employees also responded that they would utilize AI in as many work tasks as possible in order to reduce their workload. This suggests a desire to work more easily and efficiently to boost productivity.

[Real Beat] Productivity Up with AI, but... Boss from Hwaseong, Employee from Geumseong [Office Shift] (33) View original image

From management’s perspective, adopting AI can drastically improve employee performance and enhance efficiency, leading to cost reductions. Employees, too, hope that AI will alleviate their workload. The surge in workers using ChatGPT after it was released to the public highlights this motive—no one wants to pass up an easier way to work.


Although management and staff are united on productivity improvements, subtle differences in perspective emerge upon closer inspection.


According to BCG’s survey of more than 13,000 employees in 18 countries this year, 62% of executives were optimistic about implementing AI in work. Among frontline staff responding to the same question, only about 4 out of 10 expressed optimism—a gap of about 20 percentage points. At the same time, while 22% of executives said they were “worried” about AI entering the workplace, that figure almost doubled to 39% among frontline staff.


BCG noted, “Compared to a similar survey five years ago, the number of respondents optimistic about AI (regardless of position) has increased overall, while the number expressing concern has decreased. Nevertheless, leaders remained far more optimistic than frontline workers about adopting AI.”


[Real Beat] Productivity Up with AI, but... Boss from Hwaseong, Employee from Geumseong [Office Shift] (33) View original image

This gap has also affected their level of interest as indicated by how frequently they use AI at work. BCG’s survey found that 46% of all respondents had used a generative AI tool at least once, with 26% using it several times per week. By job title, 80% of executives reported using AI at least once a week, but this figure dropped to just 20% among frontline staff.


BCG assessed, "This difference is likely influenced by executives' more optimistic attitude toward AI usage." It means leaders are more enthusiastic and frequent users of AI than frontline staff.

◆ Employees’ Deepest Concerns: "Will AI Replace My Job?"

This gap appears to originate from employees’ anxiety over potential job loss. Introducing AI to the workplace and reducing staff numbers may mean cost savings for management, but it naturally raises fears among employees about losing their own jobs. This explains why optimism is higher among management but anxiety is greater among employees.


The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)’s report released last March, "The Impact of AI in the Workplace," reveals this divergence. Survey results therein showed that 1 out of 2 employers predicted that AI adoption would not significantly affect the total number of jobs. One in five even believed the number of jobs would increase.


However, over half of employee respondents said they feared losing their jobs within the next 10 years due to AI. About 20% were "extremely" concerned about job loss. Furthermore, over 40% believed that AI adoption would lead to lower wages within 10 years, while far fewer—only in the 10% range—believed wages would increase as a result.


The data indicates a substantial number of employees expect negative outcomes—loss of jobs and pay cuts—should AI be implemented in their workplaces.

EPA Yonhap News

EPA Yonhap News

View original image

The OECD’s survey was conducted in January–February of last year, before the current boom in generative AI. Given the heightened fears around job loss since the AI wave swept the world this year, this anxiety is likely even stronger now. The OECD explained, "Employees who had used AI were even more likely to worry about losing their jobs within the next 10 years." Since the beginning of 2023, it has become much easier for workers to use various AI chatbots such as ChatGPT and Google Bard.


Adding to this, IBM in the United States announced in May that it would replace 30% of its back-office support staff with AI, and in the same month, U.S. HR consulting firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas (CG&C) reported that 3,900 employees had been laid off due to AI. These successive announcements have likely intensified workers' anxiety.

◆ What Company Leaders Care About Is “How to Use AI in Work”

So, do executives hope to adopt AI mainly to reduce headcount and cut costs? Survey data on executives' motives for introducing AI are somewhat mixed. In the MS survey, the top reason for adoption was “improving productivity,” while the least important was “reducing headcount.” In other words, few managers were prioritizing staff reduction as their rationale for implementing AI. In contrast, the OECD survey reported executive priorities as “improving employee performance” and “cutting staff-related costs.”


This discrepancy is interpreted as arising from the uncertain scope of AI’s workplace application and the difficulty of predicting its impact on employment.


At present, executives appear focused on leveraging AI to raise productivity and strengthen corporate competitiveness. They are considering whether—and in what roles—AI can be useful, to what degree it should be used, what ripple effects it might have, and how to address any potential problems. Because AI’s utility varies widely depending on the industry and company, and given that adopting new technology is involved, CEOs consider quick assessment of the situation crucial.


At Yale University last month, the 134th CEO Summit was held, attended by more than 200 company leaders. The AI-related insights and experiences they shared at this event shed light on their key interests in workplace AI adoption.


[Real Beat] Productivity Up with AI, but... Boss from Hwaseong, Employee from Geumseong [Office Shift] (33) View original image

Peter Orszag, the former White House budget chief and incoming CEO of global investment bank Lazard, remarked that AI can replace minor tasks at investment banks—such as summarizing meeting minutes—but said, "I tried writing emails with GPT-4, but in the end, I rewrote most of them," indicating that AI is not yet mature enough to fully replace humans.


In contrast, Xerox CEO Steven Bandrowczak stated, "AI has already reduced the number of customer technician visits by more than 40% and has achieved remarkable results in call centers as well," highlighting the company's active use of AI to boost efficiency.


Coca-Cola CEO James Quincey predicted that AI could cause massive disruption in the marketing industry. He remarked that, "With AI now able to generate images easily, the era of spending billions of dollars on marketing content could come to an end. While it's beneficial for companies to get user-generated marketing content at lower cost, it might also prove a disruptive situation."



Doug McMillon, CEO of Walmart, said, "Whether it’s AI or some other technology, what matters is identifying what problems need to be solved and focusing on them. In terms of customer and employee experience, efficiency, and supply chain, AI represents a major opportunity for us."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing