[Jjinbit] "Mixing remote work and office is difficult, something has to be sacrificed" [Office Shift](29)
[Interview] David Sax, Author of 'Things Digital Can't Do'
"Work is a Human Element Beyond Tasks, AI, and Technological Advances"
The world is swept up in an artificial intelligence (AI) frenzy. Ever since ChatGPT emerged, the race to develop AI chatbots has become a daily part of global life through search engines, work software, and more. Apple has unveiled Vision Pro, its first new product in nine years, a mixed reality (MR) headset, and signaled the revival of the metaverse. They also announced that it could be used while working, linked with Mac laptops. Digital technology is clearly dominating the office environment.
Digital technology was at the core of offices worldwide during the COVID-19 pandemic. Amid unprecedented crisis, employees everywhere opened their laptops. Meetings and conversations took place via video calls, and relationships were built in this way. While it felt like technological innovation was shining during the crisis, the term 'Zoom fatigue' became widespread, as people felt physically and mentally drained by a series of video meetings. Feelings of loneliness and isolation also increased.
"The greatest lesson the pandemic gave us is that while digital technology improves our lives, it can also make them worse. Just as not all technology is synonymous with progress, it has become clear that not all progress comes from new technology." - Book, 'Things Digital Cannot Do'
David Sax, the Canadian journalist and author known for the global bestseller 'The Revenge of Analog', explores company changes—specifically, 'what disappeared in the era of remote work'—in the first chapter of his newly released book in Korea, 'The Future Is Analog'. Having garnered significant attention from major global media outlets such as The New York Times with his previous book, David Sax reportedly interviewed around 200 experts and others while writing this new work.
Sax examines what is missing from digital technology in an era of rapid advancement and emphasizes the value of analog. On June 5, he responded to a written interview in which we asked him, in the context of remote work, about 'what we have lost.'
◆ "Resistance to Returning to the Office Is a Labor Power Struggle"
"Remote work is convenient and comfortable. There's no daily commute, and you don't have to wake up early. It gives you the time and flexibility to do things like exercise or go for a walk."
Conflicts persist globally between companies urging employees to return to the office and workers who are resistant. When asked why this phenomenon has occurred, Sax replied, "The reason is simple." For a writer who champions the importance of analog, this was a surprising response. As a journalist and author who has worked remotely all his life, he revealed that he had only once worked in an office. He understands the convenience of remote work better than anyone and is adept at using laptops, email, and video conferencing. However, Sax delved deeper beyond a simple explanation of company-employee conflicts.
"When remote work began during COVID-19, employees gained tremendous freedom and control over their time and bodies. This was unprecedented in labor relations. What we see now is ultimately a power struggle between labor and management. It's not about what is the most efficient or productive way to work, but about workers trying to maintain the autonomy they achieved over their power, body, and time—and not easily giving it up. The truly complicated part is that nothing about this is simple or easy. There is no straightforward solution that satisfies everyone."
Even for someone accustomed to remote work, Sax said the COVID-19 period was not easy. He admitted to feeling physically drained after more than two online meetings a day. Sax repeatedly emphasized that there are things digital technology simply cannot provide in the workplace. He pointed out that while digital tools allow us to share data and facts, it's difficult to communicate anything beyond that.
"Communicating in the same space through non-verbal means—much of what we 'say' is actually body language, facial expressions, gestures, or even scent. This kind of information is extremely important for our work. Although we can communicate well online, we miss a lot without even realizing it. In the long run, this comes at a cost to our understanding, our social networks, and the quality of information we exchange related to our work."
An example of this is the experience of Jennifer Kolstad, Ford Motor Company's global head of workplace design, whom Sax met during the pandemic. Kolstad said that in 2021, while designing company offices, including headquarters, she struggled to make progress through online meetings. She eventually gathered eight key employees in a conference room. An issue that had gone unresolved for months was sorted out in just three hours. By sticking ideas to the conference room walls, discussing, rearranging, and organizing as they went, the discussion quickly reached a conclusion.
◆ Negative Views on Hybrid and Childcare Remote Work Experiments
Recognizing these limitations, companies have increasingly implemented 'hybrid work'—combining remote and in-office work—since last year. The aim is to supplement the shortcomings of remote work by requiring staff to spend some time physically in the office. However, Sax expressed a negative view on these work styles.
"The reality in the analog world is that you can't be in two places at once. Mixing remote and office work is very difficult. No matter how smart you are, no matter how well you schedule, or how flexible the office is, people can't be in two places simultaneously, and something always has to be sacrificed. For someone like me, writing alone, it may be easy, but for a company with more than five employees—let alone a giant like Hyundai—it's extremely difficult."
Sax also voiced concern about the remote work for parents policy that the Korean and Japanese governments introduced this year as part of their low birthrate measures. As a father of two, he shared his own pandemic experience juggling childcare with work. He noted that even answering these interview questions only became possible after 10 p.m., once his children were asleep.
"I think childcare is the most important issue in the world of work. It's connected to birth rates, the economy, and the role of women as workers. What I observed during the pandemic is that parents don't want to do childcare during work hours. It's impossible to balance. It's a form of torture. Ask any parent who has worked from home while caring for children during the pandemic. What parents really want is 'flexibility'—the ability to pause work briefly in the early morning, or start a bit later, so they can take their kids to school or have dinner together as a family."
◆ "Work Is Part of Being Human... It Is More Than Just a Task"
The original title of Sax's new book released in Korea is 'The Future Is Analog: How to Create a More Human World.' Ever since 'The Revenge of Analog,' Sax has emphasized the importance of humanity that we often lose sight of in a digital world. Focusing on analog, he was asked, "Can digital and analog coexist harmoniously in our work environment?"
"I think we've already achieved harmony. Most people work with both people and computers, and we know when and how to combine them most effectively. There's no one arguing that we should work entirely without computers. Similarly, thinking that making everything digital would be better is naive. We've tried fully remote work, and if it had been so perfectly wonderful, nobody would want to return to the office. The key is to keep finding the right balance. It won't ever be perfect, but that's okay—the friction will lead us to better results."
During the interview, Sax prompted reflection on the meaning of work itself. He stressed that it's not just about performing tasks with digital technology but about forming relationships with others and building personal life through those interactions.
"Work doesn't happen outside of life itself. We spend more of our waking hours working than doing anything else—more than eating, exercising, having sex, or engaging in cultural activities. All the relationships, friendships, learning, information, jokes, sights, and sounds we acquire in the workplace are major parts of life. Just because we can perform a 'task' remotely doesn't mean all those other things aren't important. Think of a friend you met at work, or even a partner or mentor. Are those relationships any less valuable just because they are connected to the office?"
"I believe work is much more than just a task. It's how we engage with the world, and it is an integral part of being human. The future of work will always be connected to that aspect of humanity, regardless of the next technological wave such as the AI boom."
About David Sax
- Canadian journalist and author
- Regular columnist for The New York Times, The New Yorker, and Bloomberg
- Author of 'The Revenge of Analog' (2016), 'The Soul of an Entrepreneur' (2021), and 'Things Digital Cannot Do' (2023)
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.